Daat Emet
  • Torah, Science & Ethics
    • Pamphlets
    • Scientific Errors in Torah
    • Religion & Ethics
    • Mitzvahs
    • Religion Caught in Its Own Net
  • Torah & Talmud
    • Weekly Portion
    • Torah Text
    • Talmud Issues
    • Daily Peppers
  • Questions & Answers
  • Who We Are
    • About Daat Emet
    • Our Supporters
    • Support Us
  • English
    • עברית (Hebrew)
    • Русский (Russian)
    • Yiddish
    • Français (French)
  • Torah, Science & Ethics
    • Pamphlets
    • Scientific Errors in Torah
    • Religion & Ethics
    • Mitzvahs
    • Religion Caught in Its Own Net
  • Torah & Talmud
    • Weekly Portion
    • Torah Text
    • Talmud Issues
    • Daily Peppers
  • Questions & Answers
  • Who We Are
    • About Daat Emet
    • Our Supporters
    • Support Us
  • English
    • עברית (Hebrew)
    • Русский (Russian)
    • Yiddish
    • Français (French)
Daat Emet
  • Torah, Science & Ethics
    • Pamphlets
    • Scientific Errors in Torah
    • Religion & Ethics
    • Mitzvahs
    • Religion Caught in Its Own Net
  • Torah & Talmud
    • Weekly Portion
    • Torah Text
    • Talmud Issues
    • Daily Peppers
  • Questions & Answers
  • Who We Are
    • About Daat Emet
    • Our Supporters
    • Support Us
  • English
    • עברית (Hebrew)
    • Русский (Russian)
    • Yiddish
    • Français (French)
  • Torah, Science & Ethics
    • Pamphlets
    • Scientific Errors in Torah
    • Religion & Ethics
    • Mitzvahs
    • Religion Caught in Its Own Net
  • Torah & Talmud
    • Weekly Portion
    • Torah Text
    • Talmud Issues
    • Daily Peppers
  • Questions & Answers
  • Who We Are
    • About Daat Emet
    • Our Supporters
    • Support Us
  • English
    • עברית (Hebrew)
    • Русский (Russian)
    • Yiddish
    • Français (French)
One who urinates from a roof into the public domain on the Sabbath
Home » Daily Peppers
Yaron Yadan 09/23/2009
One who urinates from a roof into the public domain on the Sabbath

The early sages (the Tana’aim) ruled that one of the activities forbidden on the Sabbath is the removal of items from the private to the public domain or the opposite. Therefore they forbade a person from standing in a private domain and urinating into a public domain or vice versa, or standing in a private domain and spitting into a public domain or vice versa, for urine and spit are considered to be items which one is forbidden from transporting from domain to domain.The matter is so grave that one who urinates or spits from domain to domain is liable to the death penalty, and if he did so without intent, he is liable to bring a sacrifice to atone for his error. One of the sages, Rava, asked about a case in which a man stands on the edge of a roof, with his body in a private domain but his sex organ over the edge of the roof, in the public domain — is he permitted to urinate into the public domain or not? What is under debate? On one hand, it may be permitted because the urine exits from the meatus, at the head of the penis, which is already in the public domain; there is no removal from the private to the public domains, only from a public domain t a public domain, which is permitted. On the other hand, it may be forbidden as the urine emanated from his body — from his bladder — and his body is in a private domain, so he moved it from a private domain to a public. [This issue was not resolved in the Talmud.]
Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Eruvin 98b-99a

About the Author

ירון ידען View all posts by Yaron Yadan

ירון ידען (נולד בטבריה ב-8 בדצמבר 1961) הוא פעיל חברתי ומייסד ארגון "דעת אמת" העומד בראש מפלגת אור.

Additional Peppers
Samson ground Philistine women in prison

Samson ground Philistine women in prison

Is one permitted to have sex with a pregnant woman?

Is one permitted to have sex with a pregnant woman?

Having sexual relations with a virgin on the Sabbath: permitted or forbidden?

Having sexual relations with a virgin on the Sabbath: permitted or forbidden?

Were the people killed by Elisha children or youths?

Were the people killed by Elisha children or youths?

On the Sabbath, should one use pottery or a stone to wipe the anus?

On the Sabbath, should one use pottery or a stone to wipe the anus?

Can bread crumbs be bewitched?

Can bread crumbs be bewitched?

Nevuchadnezzar wanted to have sex with King Tzedkiyahu

Nevuchadnezzar wanted to have sex with King Tzedkiyahu

© 2016 כל הזכויות שמורות לדעת אמת.
Skip to content
Open toolbar Accessibility Tools

Accessibility Tools

  • Increase TextIncrease Text
  • Decrease TextDecrease Text
  • GrayscaleGrayscale
  • High ContrastHigh Contrast
  • Negative ContrastNegative Contrast
  • Light BackgroundLight Background
  • Links UnderlineLinks Underline
  • Readable FontReadable Font
  • Reset Reset